Topic: SURVEY 2 Results

[Recovering Noorholic]

11 people participated in this survey, up from our previous record of 10.

As expected, GN scored poorly in almost every category. However - relatively speaking (for this board) - he did surprisingly well as a host of past-life/reincarnation shows. Also, as expected, Knapp "almost" swept the UFO category with one dissenter voting Ian.

The full results:

1. Who does the best job hosting shows about Prophecy / 2012 / Alternate History?

Majority Answer: Ian Punnett

Noory - 9.1%
Knapp - 36.4%
Punnett - 54.5%


2. Who does the best job hosting shows about UFOs?

Majority Answer: George Knapp

Noory - 0%
Knapp - 90.9%
Punnett - 9.1%

3. Who does the best job hosting shows about Life-after-Death / Reincarnation / Ghosts / EVP?

Majority Answer: George Knapp

Noory - 27.3%
Knapp - 54.5%
Punnett - 18.2%


4. Who does the best job hosting shows involving conspiracy, politics, economics and trend forecasting?

Majority Answer: George Knapp

Noory - 9.1%
Knapp - 54.5%
Punnett - 36.4%

5. Who does the best job hosting topics about "Real Science" (e.g. Michio Kaku, Phil Platt, etc.)?

Majority Answer: George Knapp

Noory - 0%
Knapp - 90.9%
Punnett - 9.1%

[bobcollum]

That is exactly how I voted, though I'm willing to let Knapp have at the first one as well, I'm sure he could handle it.

George Snoory got way more of the vote than I figured he would.... 

[Recovering Noorholic]

I voted for Noory on the past-life question (though only on that one). If Lisa L. books him a good guest and not one of the crackpots I think he usually does a good interview. I don't know if it's just that he's actually interested in this topic and merely going through the motions on the rest or what.

Even if you agree with me, though, the problem is that one good show and 19 crap shows per month isn't really the best ratio.

[Phantastic SanShiSan]

I voted for Noory on the past-life question (though only on that one).

Same here.  He's got that "flaky quotient" that goes well with the subject matter (as far as my opinion on the subject goes).

I also gave Ian the first one due to the "alternate history" aspect. I haven't heard Knapp enough to really judge, but seeing as he's the most serious of the 3, and he's a UFO specialist, he got all the others.

[Recovering Noorholic]

So that accounts for 2 of Noory's 3 votes ... I assume the third was Noory himself?