Author Topic: How to ruin good web design  (Read 678 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

How to ruin good web design
« on: March 07, 2009, 02:41:00 PM »

This is a bit of a twist on the old thread about gag-inducing websites.

http://www.rochellesparrow.com/

is the site of Snoory's Friday first hour guest.

The good news:  The basic layout is well done.  The size is good. The colors match the theme and are pleasant together. On the FIRST page, the navigation is intuitive, and matches the design well.  Good start!  Those are among the first considerations when doing a "wire-frame" (website mock up)

But then, the designer went bonkers.

The contrast between the text and the background is not high enough.  Anyone with color perception issue would not be able to read it - and yes, that matters.

There is too much variety in the fonts.  Stick to one font, or font family, with the possible exception of headers or logos.

Centered text belongs on wedding invitations and death announcements.  IOW - it is considered overly formal for most uses.

The navigation layout changes.  That's not unusual when you go from a portal page to content pages - but the portal page is flash based, and contains a lot of content.     BAD form!  And confusing enough to make visitors leave sooner than the designer would like.

Those are venal sins

Now for mortal sins:


Calendars and event information has been imported from some kind of spread sheet application.  That's fine on an intranet where everyone is used to your format.  On the web, it's the kiss of death UNLESS you make sure it is consistent with the rest of the design, and FOR THE LOVE OF GOD readable!

Flash portals are now considered okay - they can be indexed by most spiders and there  are things the developer can do to make sure they are.  HOWEVER, this one is way too busy.  It moves too fast, has too many actions going on at the same time, and too wide a variety of effects (as with fonts, less is more)  There is a toggle switch that should allow the viewer to turn off at least one of the flash presentation, but it doesn't WORK!

Last, while I know you guys have busted my chops before when I mention web design and medical issues, it is a real consideration when it comes to accessability issues, and accessibility is the reason why web standards exist in the first place. This portal is an invitation to seasickness, at the LEAST. 

---
I'm also not sure it can be navigated if you don't use a mouse (many don't).  But, I'm just learning about keyboard accessibility myself - so that's just a random thought.

Now, I need to go find some ibuprofen, since I ended up with a throbbing head by looking at this site long enough to offer opinions. 

AS for the woman herself, I haven't (yet) heard her speak, so I have no opinion on how much snake oil she has to sell.
 

Centurion73

  • Guest
Re: How to ruin good web design
« Reply #1 on: March 07, 2009, 11:18:21 PM »
I don't know anything about web design and stuff like that but after going to her site I can see a lot of your points and I agree with you and I hate that font shit she has.

Quote
Last, while I know you guys have busted my chops before when I mention web design and medical issues,

I never read your rants on that I will if you send me them as it is a big issue that often gets overlooked. I know sometimes the flash rate on a banner or something does lead me to get a migraine and I know that certain colors & flash rates can bring on epileptic seizures in some with that condition.

Re: How to ruin good web design
« Reply #2 on: March 08, 2009, 12:03:36 AM »
Quote
I know sometimes the flash rate on a banner or something does lead me to get a migraine and I know that certain colors & flash rates can bring on epileptic seizures in some with that condition.

Well!  Praise whatever Powers there may be and pass the ammunition!  SOMEBODY here gets it!  ;D

Centurion73

  • Guest
Re: How to ruin good web design
« Reply #3 on: March 08, 2009, 12:27:29 AM »
Well!  Praise whatever Powers there may be and pass the ammunition!  SOMEBODY here gets it!  ;D


I have a person in my family that cannot drive in early spring or late fall because of the strobe effect from sunlight coming through the deciduous trees has caused her seizures. If any of you doubt this I beg of you to please at least look at the following site, esp if you have a family member with this condition or deal with anyone who has it.

www.epilepsy.org.uk/info/photo_other.html

Re: How to ruin good web design
« Reply #4 on: March 08, 2009, 12:40:21 AM »
I have a person in my family that cannot drive in early spring or late fall because of the strobe effect from sunlight coming through the deciduous trees and has caused her seizures.

No doubt.  This was poo-pooed as a myth at one point, but, based on the idea that this WAS a myth, I took a teenager who was a client to the county fair one year, and agreed to take him on one of those rides that flashes, makes outrageous noises, goes round and round and then does it all again backwards.  He had a grand mal about 3 minutes in. I'm still not sure who suffered more, this boy with his seizure, or me - strapped in tight beside him - with the resulting bruises from his flailing, my voice which was raw for days after screaming above the racket of the fair for them to stop the ride, and my HUGE guilt!

Since then, the medical establishment has acknowledged that this is not a myth.  I get migraines from that kind of flashing, and I knew a man who got debilitating migraines, even on medication, just from florescent lighting flicker  I could not even perceive (and I can see that sort of thing well, as a rule.)

That county fair experience, BTW - resulted in one of the few possibly paranormal experiences of my life.  But that is another thread.  ;)

Re: How to ruin good web design
« Reply #5 on: March 08, 2009, 03:23:48 AM »
Didn't read all the posts but if you want to ruin your website just load it up with flash crap and a dozen java scripts running in the background and music for sure. The websites that also annoy me are the ones with the entire content on one page and if printed out would consume 500 sheets of paper.